ETS vs seasonal naive

Here, you will compare ETS forecasts against seasonal naive forecasting for 20 years of cement, which contains quarterly cement production using time series cross-validation for 4 steps ahead. Because this takes a while to run, a shortened version of the cement series will be available in your workspace.

The second argument for tsCV() must return a forecast object, so you need a function to fit a model and return forecasts. Recall:

> args(tsCV)
function (y, forecastfunction, h = 1, ...)

In this exercise you will use an existing forecasting function as well as one that has been created for you. Remember, sometimes simple methods work better than more sophisticated methods!

This exercise is part of the course

Forecasting in R

Exercise instructions

A function to return ETS forecasts, fets(), has been written for you.
Apply tsCV() for both ETS and seasonal naive methods to the cement data for a forecast horizon of 4. Use the newly created fets and the existing snaive functions as your forecast function argument for e1 and e2, respectively.
Compute the MSE of the resulting 4-step errors and remove missing values. The expressions for calculating MSE have been provided for you, but the second optional arguments have not (you've used them before).
Save the best MSE as bestmse. You can simply copy the entire line of code that generates the best MSE from the previous instruction.

Hands-on interactive exercise

Have a go at this exercise by completing this sample code.

# Function to return ETS forecasts
fets <- function(y, h) {
  forecast(ets(y), h = h)
}

# Apply tsCV() for both methods
e1 <- tsCV(___, ___, h = ___)
e2 <- tsCV(___, ___, h = ___)

# Compute MSE of resulting errors (watch out for missing values)
mean(e1^2, ___)
mean(e2^2, ___)

# Copy the best forecast MSE
bestmse <- ___

Edit and Run Code

This exercise is part of the course

Forecasting in R

IntermediateSkill Level

4.8+

Start Course for Free

The first thing to do in any data analysis task is to plot the data. Graphs enable many features of the data to be visualized, including patterns, unusual observations, and changes over time. The features that are seen in plots of the data must then be incorporated, as far as possible, into the forecasting methods to be used.

Exercise 1: Welcome to Forecasting Using R Exercise 2: Creating time series objects in R Exercise 3: Time series plots Exercise 4: Seasonal plots Exercise 5: Trends, seasonality, and cyclicity Exercise 6: Autocorrelation of non-seasonal time series Exercise 7: Autocorrelation of seasonal and cyclic time series Exercise 8: Match the ACF to the time series Exercise 9: White noise Exercise 10: Stock prices and white noise

In this chapter, you will learn general tools that are useful for many different forecasting situations. It will describe some methods for benchmark forecasting, methods for checking whether a forecasting method has adequately utilized the available information, and methods for measuring forecast accuracy. Each of the tools discussed in this chapter will be used repeatedly in subsequent chapters as you develop and explore a range of forecasting methods.

Exercise 1: Forecasts and potential futures Exercise 2: Naive forecasting methods Exercise 3: Fitted values and residuals Exercise 4: Checking time series residuals Exercise 5: Training and test sets Exercise 6: Evaluating forecast accuracy of non-seasonal methods Exercise 7: Evaluating forecast accuracy of seasonal methods Exercise 8: Do I have a good forecasting model?Exercise 9: Time series cross-validation Exercise 10: Using tsCV() for time series cross-validation

Forecasts produced using exponential smoothing methods are weighted averages of past observations, with the weights decaying exponentially as the observations get older. In other words, the more recent the observation, the higher the associated weight. This framework generates reliable forecasts quickly and for a wide range of time series, which is a great advantage and of major importance to applications in business.

Exercise 1: Exponentially weighted forecasts Exercise 2: Simple exponential smoothing Exercise 3: SES vs naive Exercise 4: Exponential smoothing methods with trend Exercise 5: Holt's trend methods Exercise 6: Exponential smoothing methods with trend and seasonality Exercise 7: Holt-Winters with monthly data Exercise 8: Holt-Winters method with daily data Exercise 9: State space models for exponential smoothing Exercise 10: Automatic forecasting with exponential smoothing Exercise 11: ETS vs seasonal naive

Current Exercise

Exercise 12: Match the models to the time series Exercise 13: When does ETS fail?

ARIMA models provide another approach to time series forecasting. Exponential smoothing and ARIMA models are the two most widely-used approaches to time series forecasting, and provide complementary approaches to the problem. While exponential smoothing models are based on a description of the trend and seasonality in the data, ARIMA models aim to describe the autocorrelations in the data.

Exercise 1: Transformations for variance stabilization Exercise 2: Box-Cox transformations for time series Exercise 3: Non-seasonal differencing for stationarity Exercise 4: Seasonal differencing for stationarity Exercise 5: ARIMA models Exercise 6: Automatic ARIMA models for non-seasonal time series Exercise 7: Forecasting with ARIMA models Exercise 8: Comparing auto.arima() and ets() on non-seasonal data Exercise 9: Seasonal ARIMA models Exercise 10: Automatic ARIMA models for seasonal time series Exercise 11: Exploring auto.arima() options Exercise 12: Comparing auto.arima() and ets() on seasonal data

The time series models in the previous chapters work well for many time series, but they are often not good for weekly or hourly data, and they do not allow for the inclusion of other information such as the effects of holidays, competitor activity, changes in the law, etc. In this chapter, you will look at some methods that handle more complicated seasonality, and you consider how to extend ARIMA models in order to allow other information to be included in the them.

Exercise 1: Dynamic regression Exercise 2: Forecasting sales allowing for advertising expenditure Exercise 3: Forecasting electricity demand Exercise 4: Dynamic harmonic regression Exercise 5: Forecasting weekly data Exercise 6: Harmonic regression for multiple seasonality Exercise 7: Forecasting call bookings Exercise 8: TBATS models Exercise 9: TBATS models for electricity demand Exercise 10: Your future in forecasting!